Are we overcomplicating financial literacy? πŸ˜‰


​

In this issue: Promoting portionsaving, practicing meansliving and encouraging longinvesting.

"Working to help parents raise money-smart kids."

​​3 Ideas to Share & Save​
​(Click the link above πŸ‘† to read this week's edition on the web.)

Hello, friends!

Last week, I wrote to you about trying to beat the market:

"Research suggests that only 1% of the very top-tier of money managers outperform, and on the rare occasion they do it is hard to distinguish skill from luck." [emphasis mine]
β€”JL Collins, The Simple Path to Wealth​

My second reading of JL Collins' The Simple Path to Wealth convinced me to share some ideas I've been mulling over.

For instance, are we overcomplicating financial literacy?

Yes.

So this week, I want to share some terms I've recently coined. Based on timeless ideas, all three help us focus on (and help our kids grasp) those key habits without which the rest of financial literacy learning won't matter.

β€” 1 β€”

Portionsaving:

"If you want to know whether you are destined to be a success or failure in life, you can easily find out. The test is simple and invaluable. Are you able to save money? If not, drop out. You will lose. You may think not, but you will lose as sure as you live. The seed of success is not in you."
β€”James Jay Hill, railroad tycoon

Harsh? Yes. But an important point to acknowledge? Also yes.

Once we begin earning money, we must also begin saving it. (I wish it hadn't taken me as long as it did to internalize this. 😳)

So enter portionsaving β€” saving a portion of anything you make. 10% is reasonable, although 50% might be more appropriate if your goal is early financial independence.

But saving, of course, hinges on income:

"No mindset in the world can make up for an insufficient balance."
"You can't prove that mindset matters, but I can prove that income matters."
β€”Nick Maggiulli, Of Dollars and Data​

We can introduce an automated savings habit in a weekly allowance, our kids' first form of income:

video preview​

Then when they get older and find work, we can help them start a Roth IRA. And as we've discussed before, matching the money they save, a topic I cover with Art of Allowance Podcast guest Bill Dwight, is a terrific incentive we parents can provide to promote portionsaving.

β€” 2 β€”

Meansliving: Despite whatever income our kids make, they are doomed to live hand to mouth if they can't keep their costs down. (I reframe this concept as ensuring their gazoutas ["goes out of"] fall below their gazintas ["goes into"] in this essay.) So they need to learn to live beneath or within their means. Put another way, they should practice meansliving.

In a world of in-your-face spending, our kids must discover controlled consumption by getting to the bottom of what they actually want. And this process is not as easy as it sounds. Because so much desire is "mimetic," or based on seeing what others have, I sense most people don't really know what they want. Even some older adults can't figure it out!

Since experience is the only way to learn, I advocate for starting an allowance and a money conversation as early as possible. But as podcast guest Veronica Dangerfield explains, meansliving is particularly hard for young people whose primary goal is just to fit in:

video preview​

"The American Dream" may seem affirming and worth striving for, but it often conjures up thoughts of things. And we know the joy we get from acquiring stuff is fleeting. So the sooner our kids stop trying to keep up with the proverbial Joneses and instead practice meansliving, the better off they'll be:

video preview​

Who knows, maybe they'll realize they want financial freedom and commit to 50% portionsaving. πŸ€·πŸ»β€β™‚οΈ

β€” 3 β€”

Longinvesting: Our kids have time on their side, and we want to do everything possible to help them leverage it by taking advantage of compound interest. In other words, we need to encourage longinvesting.

But isn't investing complicated? And don't you need an advisor?

"Unfortunately most advisors don't get better results. Investing only seems complex because the financial industry goes to great lengths to make it seem complex. Indeed, many investments are complex. But as you now already understand, not only are simple index investments easier, they are more effective."
β€”JL Collins, The Simple Path to Wealth

Keep. It. Simple.

So your kids have set up a Roth IRA (or a Traditional IRA, 401(k) or brokerage account). Once the money is deposited in one of these vehicles, they need to decide on an investment. But there are seemingly endless options. And choice can be paralyzing. πŸ˜΅β€πŸ’«

So take JL Collins' advice to find one total stock market index fund, like Vanguard's VTSAX (or similar funds offered by other institutions).

Done. Overwhelm over.

One thing you probably don't need? A stock market simulation. In fact, a favorite thinker of mine about kids and investing, Will Rainey, explains why games may encourage the opposite behaviors you're trying to instill:

video preview​

And if your kids are itching to play the market, encourage them to use a small portion of their investable money to buy a stock they know. Podcast guest Evan Wilson provides useful advice here:

video preview​

Just this past week, the latest "Financial Illiteracy Epidemic" article has been making the rounds (at least in my world). We've seen this before. For years. And we will continue to get the same result if we keep taking the same approach.

Complexity overwhelms, and overwhelmed kids (or, frankly, adults) don't pay attention. Budgeting, credit, debt, insurance, account types, identity theft and interest rates are all meaningful areas of financial literacy learning. However, none will matter one iota if our kids don't develop the habits of portionsaving, meansliving and longinvesting.

Pour the foundation. Then build the house.

Let's keep it simple and enjoy the journey!

John,
Chief Mammal

P.S. Please consult with a financial or investment professional before making any decisions that might affect your financial well-being.

​View this email in your browser.

Forwarded this email? Sign up here.

​

3 Ideas to Share & Save

Every Monday I share 3 ideas to help you and your family on the money-smart journey. I created "The Money Mammals" for kids and wrote The Art of Allowance book for parents like you. Won't you join me on the money-smart journey?

Read more from 3 Ideas to Share & Save

In this issue: Engaging kids with money-smart messages, empowering parents with robust resources and making a contribution to society. "Working to help parents raise money-smart kids." 3 Ideas to Share & Save(Click the link above πŸ‘† to read this week's edition on the web.) Hello, friends, I'd like to begin this installment of "3 Ideas to Share & Save" with a big thank you! πŸ™ Our readership has doubled over the past several months due to your sharing these ideas and fellow writers' referring...

In this issue: Filling your money-smart rucksack, becoming a one percenter and considering perspectives on time. "Working to help parents raise money-smart kids." 3 Ideas to Share & Save(Click the link above πŸ‘† to read this week's edition on the web.) Hello, friends! I've returned from dropping off my daughter at school, which means my wife and I are back to being empty nesters. But it also means I'm back to sharing this newsletter with you. So let's dive into this new installment! β€” 1 β€” Fill...

In this issue: Making financial literacy fun, avoiding distraction brokers and finding a rainbow. "Working to help parents raise money-smart kids." 3 Ideas to Share & Save(Click the link above πŸ‘† to read this week's edition on the web.) Hello, friends! With so many kids simmering in schools before September, Labor Day no longer feels like the ceremonial end of summer. So this edition will wrap up the season in a neat, tidy (rain)bow. And since I'm helping my daughter start up her sophomore...